Support Our Journalism
Legal Issues

Liberia: Justice Ministry Defies Court Order to Release IB Atlantic IV, Seven Crew Members

MONROVIA – The Ministry of Justice has failed to comply with a court order directing the release of the mysterious vessel IB Atlantic IV and its seven crew members by 4:00 p.m. Wednesday, November 18, raising fresh questions about the government’s continued detention of the vessel and its crew despite judicial intervention.


By Willie N. Tokpah


Assigned Circuit Judge D. Onesimus Banwon of Criminal Court ‘A’ for Montserrado County had ordered the Ministry of Justice to release the vessel and its crew by the stipulated deadline following a habeas corpus petition challenging their continued detention.

However, as of approximately 5:00 p.m. Wednesday, FrontPage Africa observed that the court’s order had not been carried out.

The seven crew members remained detained aboard the vessel, while lawyers representing them confirmed that their clients had not been released.

Judge Banwon was also observed leaving the court premises at approximately 4:00 p.m., around the time the deadline expired, with the vessel and its crew still under state custody.

The apparent failure to comply with the order has raised questions about the Ministry’s handling of the case and the legal basis for the continued detention of the vessel and its crew.

When contacted late Wednesday evening to confirm whether the vessel and its crew had been released and, if not, to explain the delay, Solicitor General Cllr. Abrahim Sillah declined to provide an explanation.

“I will refer you to find out from the court, my brother,” Sillah told FrontPage Africa.

Ministry Struggles To Explain Continued Detention

Sources within the Ministry of Justice, who spoke to FrontPage Africa on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the matter publicly, disclosed that the Ministry was still struggling to formulate an explanation for the continued detention of the vessel and its crew.

According to the sources, the difficulty stems from the fact that the public had previously been informed that an investigation was underway into the vessel’s movements and the circumstances surrounding its interception.

The sources said authorities were facing pressure to explain why the vessel and its crew remained detained despite the court’s directive and the absence of publicly disclosed investigative findings establishing grounds for their continued custody.

They further indicated that the Ministry was contemplating releasing the crew members and vessel early Thursday morning, November 19, in an apparent effort to comply with the court’s order, although the Wednesday deadline had already passed.

Such a move, if carried out, would come after the government had missed the deadline established by the court.

As of Wednesday evening, however, no official confirmation had been issued that the release had taken place.

Nearly Three Months In Custody

The detention of the IB Atlantic IV and its seven crew members has become one of Liberia’s most unusual maritime security cases, beginning with the vessel’s unexplained presence off York Island in Grand Cape Mount County in August.

The Comoros-flagged vessel initially attracted attention after lingering in Liberian coastal waters, prompting concerns among residents and security authorities about its presence, movements and possible activities.

The situation escalated when Liberian security forces, including the Armed Forces of Liberia Coast Guard, reportedly attempted to intercept the vessel as it moved farther offshore toward Rivercess County.

On August 4, then Armed Forces of Liberia Chief of Staff Major General Davidson Forleh confirmed that security forces were pursuing the vessel.

The ship reportedly evaded the initial Liberian pursuit before being intercepted by Ivorian authorities on August 9, transforming the incident into a cross-border maritime security matter.

Its interception in Côte d’Ivoire raised additional questions about how the vessel had moved from Liberia’s coastal waters into the custody of a neighboring country and what authorities had discovered during the operation.

Liberia’s Investigation And The Vessel’s Return

On August 14, Information Minister Jerolinmek M. Piah publicly confirmed that the vessel had been arrested by Ivorian authorities and disclosed that the Liberian Government was engaging its Ivorian counterpart to facilitate its return.

The government also disclosed that a Liberian fishing vessel had reportedly gone out to sea to meet the IB Atlantic IV, prompting the National Fisheries and Aquaculture Authority to investigate the circumstances surrounding the encounter.

The development widened the scope of the investigation, placing additional focus on the relationship between the foreign vessel and the Liberian fishing boat.

Questions also emerged over the vessel’s cargo, movements, initial presence off York Island and whether any prohibited materials or other suspicious items had been discovered.

Although allegations and speculation about possible contraband circulated during the incident, no publicly established findings have confirmed those allegations.

Following diplomatic and security engagements between Monrovia and Abidjan, the vessel was eventually returned to Liberia in late August, reportedly arriving on August 27 under the command of the Liberian Coast Guard.

Its return was expected to provide Liberian authorities an opportunity to conduct further investigations into its activities and the circumstances surrounding its interception.

Instead, the vessel and its seven crew members remained under security control, with no comprehensive public account of the investigation’s findings.

Court Intervention

The continued detention eventually prompted the vessel’s management and the seven crew members to seek judicial intervention through a habeas corpus petition challenging the legality of their confinement.

Judge Banwon’s order directing their release by 4:00 p.m. Wednesday represented a significant judicial intervention, placing the Ministry of Justice under a clear deadline to act.

The failure to release them by the stipulated time has brought renewed attention to compliance with judicial orders and the constitutional protections afforded to persons held by state authorities.

For the crew members, the ordeal has meant weeks of detention aboard a vessel whose movements have attracted national and regional attention.

For the government, the case presents an increasingly difficult challenge: explaining the circumstances that led to the vessel’s pursuit, its interception in Côte d’Ivoire, its return to Liberia, the prolonged detention of its crew and the apparent failure to comply with a court order directing their release.

As Wednesday night approached, the IB Atlantic IV remained in custody, its seven crew members were still detained, and the public continued to await answers to a maritime mystery that began off Liberia’s coastline and has now become a test of compliance with judicial authority.

Independent. Fearless. Liberian.

Support independent journalism

Your support helps FrontPage Africa keep investigating, informing and holding power to account, and keeps quality journalism free for every reader.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *